Friday, August 5, 2011

I Don’t Belong Here

What the hell am I doing here -  I don't belong hereThose of you have followed along for a while know that Algebra 1, was the bane of my parental existence for the entirety of my big girl’s 8th grade year.

I mean I tried everything I could think of to get that kid to just turn in her work. I begged, I pleaded, tried empathy, I remained calm, I lost my cool, I threatened, I followed through, nope, it wasn’t gonna happen, she would do her work but she would NOT TURN IT IN. I emailed the teacher, I set her up with a tutor, I took her to a professional tutoring place, both of which informed me she didn’t need help…she completely understood how to do it. But still she would not turn in the work. I called the school counselor (many times), I meet with the other school counselor, and I took her to a private counselor. Still she refused to just turn in the mother freaking homework we watched her do!

It always came back to it wasn’t her fault and my big girl insisting that she didn’t belong in that class in the first place.

I would pull out the letter from her 7th grade teacher explaining why the big girl had been placed in 9th grade Algebra, rather than 8th grade math. I would show her where the letter outlined the test score and grade requirements; I would show her where it showed her grades and her test scores and how hers were well over the minimum requirement to be placed in the advanced class. But she could not be dissuaded from her insistence that she was wrongly placed in the class.

I knew that her belief was at the root of her lack of effort…But, It. Made. No. Sense! It was a mistaken belief, and I had no idea where on earth it came from. I was very worried, that she had somehow lost confidence in herself for no apparent reason, with no logical explanation.

That is until Mr. Sunday and I went to school on the day before the revoked Chicago trip to see if our big girl had turned in her work, which she hadn’t. Me being me, I looked the teacher in the eye and said

“I just don’t understand what is going on here! Does she understand the work or not? She has always loved math and excelled in it until this year. Did she hit a wall or something? ”

“I have no idea, she doesn’t speak in class and she refuses to ask for help.”

At this point my big girl chimes in crying with, “I keep telling you that I DON’T BELONG IN THIS CLASS IN THE FIRST PLACE!”

As I start with “No, honey we have been over and over this and that is just not TRUE”

Her teacher, that she has had all freaking year interrupts me with,

“No she is right. Mrs. So and So put a LOT of kids in this class who don’t belong here because she was retiring and she wouldn’t have to deal with the fall out.”

I was stunned…Me stunned…into silence…yes, I am sure my eyes were bugging out and the vein in my neck was popping…but I could say nothing. Oh, My Goodness, so this is what she has been telling her class all year. This is why my daughter who easily qualified for the class was insisting that she didn’t belong, and all of the king’s horses, tutors, and counselors or mommy could convince her otherwise.

Now, I clearly understood what had happen and how, but I had no idea how to fix it. I had no idea how to give her love of math or self-confidence back, or how to combat a solid year of being given the message that some of them weren’t good enough and didn’t belong and her willingness to internalize it and take it on as her truth. Oh what a mess.

Comments (14)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
The damage incompetent teachers do :( (I was an eighth grade math teacher in one of my previous lives)
1 reply · active 712 weeks ago
I just can’t imagine why she felt the need to inform her class that she thought some of them were in the wrong class…not a good way to start things off.
That is not cool. Your sweet girl...I feel bad for her. Just keep encouraging her. She is obviously smart and deserves to be there. That teacher on the other hand, obviously does not. Best of luck to your daughter :)
1 reply · active 712 weeks ago
She looks so so so much like you. <3
1 reply · active 712 weeks ago
Wow. Just. Wow.

I'd be so angry I wouldn't be able to see straight.

If I'd actually been able to speak, I'd ask why she thought that this particular child didn't belong in the class. But I very much doubt I would have been able to say that.

Good luck rebuilding her confidence.
WHAT IS WRONG WITH THAT TEACHER?? OMG. Why would an adult...a teacher no less...tell children something like that? Poor kids. :(
That kind of makes me want to hurt someone. Your daughter is beautiful. Hope she finds her love of math again. The world needs more beautiful, smart chicks.
That is insane. What happened to teachers encouraging us to be all that we can become??? I am so sorry for you all.
Ah school, so glad it's over for us. Hopefully your daughter can find some, "screw you, I'll show you I belong here" attitude or whatever will work for her. Some teachers are great but some are just awful at what they do.

Great tune and girls who are good at math rock!
I know plenty of people who only went in to teaching because it was the only job that gave off weekends, most holidays and ALL summer as well as gave decent benefits. If that's how most of them choose to join the profession it's no wonder why our education system is failing.

There are some teachers who truly shine but with tenure, it seems that a lot of them reach a point where they are pretty useless and shouldn't be teaching any more but we can't get rid of them.

Math was NOT my forte. However, I had a math teacher in high school who made my life miserable. Would make us come up to the board and explain to the class how we completed a problem. If we weren't doing it his way (even if we got the correct result) he would berate us in front of the whole class. I lost it one day and left the class in tears. My father went to the next parent teacher conference and made sure to do the same thing to him in front of all the other parents. Didn't have any problems with that teacher again...

Just keep encouraging her; maybe even a little more than you normally would and hopefully it will take.
Sunday - can you get her mad enough to prove the teacher wrong and have to eat his words?
so, children.......ever children raised in a stable home with two parents are suseptable to internalizing bullshit labels. that they will lower their appitudes/perform to the lowest level of expectation. teachers have an enormous power in the lives of children. so, what about parents who label their children.......or step children......or foster children,.......or adopted children.

so, let's start a campaign where we call children.........,WONDERFULL, SPECIAL, FABULOUS, WELL-BEHAVED, WINNER, SUPER-SMART, SUPER-STAR, ANGEL..........you name it. find that wonerful quality and SING it out.......ALL DAY.......EVERY DAY.

Post a new comment

Comments by

Pages 381234 »

 
Powered by Blogger