Sunday, February 27, 2011

Mother What?

The other day I left a comment on a post at Birth Mother /First Mother Form. In my comment I typed “natural mother” and immediately I thought maybe I should change it to birth mother or first mother or my new personal favorite “whatever mother” because apparently somebody will be inevitably offended by any one of those terms. My own natural mother just may be offended by all of them feeling that she needs no qualification of her role.

I have had a Birth, First, Natural mother. I had an older sister who was more a “mothering” figure to me when I was young than my natural mother ever was as mothering has never come naturally to my first mother. (My kids still despite all corrections and explanations continue to believe my sister is their grandmother.)

I have had nannies after my natural mother left. I have a step mother, who I am now affectionately referring to as my father’s wife, as “mothering” me is not something that come naturally to her either.

I have had foster mothers, a “Surrogate mother”, a “one on one”, and countless staff who filled the parenting role for me over the years.

I had my momma, the mother of a friend. Who fed, clothed, sheltered and loved me until the day she died. And she was the closest thing to a “real mother” I have ever had.

I have heard from adoptees that adoptive parents don’t like the term “natural mother” because it implies that adoption is an unnatural way to become a parent. Well, this is the part where I offend some people I care about and respect…adoption is not the natural way to become a parent. Adoption is the legal way to become a parent. That is not a slam it is just the cold hard truth.

I underwent in vitro fertilization, that is the scientific way to become a parent…the end results (in my case) would have ended up with my having a natural child, however the process was anything but.
There a lot of children right here in this country who conceived naturally borne into families whom will not or cannot raise them. That is a sad fact.

Whether you are a “natural”, “first”, “birth”, “surrogate”, “foster”, “adoptive” I am not sure that the descriptions/qualifiers used in conversation to avoid confusion in a highly complicated situation matter nearly as much as the “Real” relationships that those descriptions can never do justice.

Comments (14)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I am not offended by the term and feel it is the right of the adoptee to use whichever term feels "right" to them. In our house I use "first mother" or 'birth mother" as at present these are terms my children choose over anything else. I don't feel like the term "natural " mother slams adoptive parents. What I do wonder about though is the irony of using that term for women to whom mothering does not appear to be natural. To me a "natural" mother is one who nurtures, loves and puts the well being of her children first . And I guess as I re-read the end of your excellent post I see that for me the term quantifies a relationship (as in a pattern of behavior) as opposed to a societal designation. Definately food for the grist mill of my brain! :-)
1 reply · active 735 weeks ago
I know, right?! I always think it is a bit of an oxymoron calling my mother my “natural mother”. She is a nice person; she is a great story teller, good to her friends, but a Natural Mother …not so much.
My recent post My Whatever Mother on BlogTalk Radio
Makes sense to me. I agree, those in that situation get to make the call.

Side note: I'm reading Three Little Words. Have you read it?
My recent post Moon Child
1 reply · active 735 weeks ago
Nice post. I can't quite figure out what to call mine so I tend to dally between terms. Wish she and I could just agree on something but that would require communication of which there is none between us. Maybe I should just call her 'ghost'? LOL. I am trying to make a funny...
My recent post A Quick Update
1 reply · active 735 weeks ago
Ahh I never thought of natural that way before in this context. I always thought about in the way you describe, that it made my relationship with my family unnatural, which to me of course it isn't. I never thought of it in the way you hear at baby showers etc., like, "oh, is she ever good with the baby already, she must be a natural". For me it's about what feels right to me, what will be most useful in differentiating, and I take into consideration most times how whomever I'm speaking to feels, even going so far as to ask if they find whatever term I've used offensive. It's when people start telling me what's "real" and what's not that I can get pissy.
My recent post Since you asked
1 reply · active 735 weeks ago
Ahh I never thought of natural that way before in this context. I always thought about in the way you describe, that it made my relationship with my family unnatural, which to me of course it isn't. I never thought of it in the way you hear at baby showers etc., like, "oh, is she ever good with the baby already, she must be a natural". For me it's about what feels right to me, what will be most useful in differentiating, and I take into consideration most times how whomever I'm speaking to feels, even going so far as to ask if they find whatever term I've used offensive. It's when people start telling me what's "real" and what's not that I can get pissy.
My recent post Since you asked
"...adoption is not the natural way to become a parent. Adoption is the legal way to become a parent. That is not a slam it is just the cold hard truth."

I agree with this, even though it didn't occur to me until a few years ago.

I also agree with you that people can be great parents or awful parents, no matter the labels they wear. I was fortunate to get great aparents who love me with all they have. I also feel fortunate--at least today--to have an original/first/natural family who is helping me to understand more about myself in deeper terms. It is a complicated thing, adoption. At least IMO, and in my experience.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
This is difficult for me because I am the adoptive mom and want to say the right things always! Of course, that is not possible;) I call their Mom's (in China and Korea) their first mom's only because I have read from adult adoptees that birth mom is offensive.

It is difficult.
My recent post Celebration of cell churches!
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
I know, it is hard; I don’t want to offend people. But sometimes I think taking offence when none was meant or picking every work apart is a way to avoid having the hard conversations about child welfare, adoption and foster care.
My recent post Momma’s Super Girl
Wow, this is an eye opener...as a mom who is probably all of the above (in one situation or another) I didn't know that birth mother was offensive?!?!? Yikes. I need to re-think..and prepare.

Rita Brennan Freay
@Rita4kids
ritabrennanfreay.com
My recent post Family crests- family ancestry- or Justin Bieber…you decide!

Post a new comment

Comments by

Pages 381234 »

 
Powered by Blogger